Difficulties in Diagnosing Asbestosis | Asbestosis Diagnosis
Email Us
Menu
  • About Us
    • Meet Our Team
    • Blog
  • Further Information
    • Complaints
    • Funding Information
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms & Conditions
  • FAQs
  • Contact Us
Solicitor Newcastle
Request Free Consultation
0800 7313982
0191 5656308
Menu
  • Accident at Work
  • Asbestos & Mesothelioma
    • Mesothelioma
    • Pleural Thickening
    • Asbestosis
    • Pleural Effusion
    • Pleural Plaque
    • Lung Cancer
  • Medical Negligence Claims
    • Medical Negligence Claims
    • Accident & Emergency
    • Appendicitis
    • Bowel Injuries
    • Cauda Equina Syndrome
    • Pressure Sores / Pressure Ulcers
    • Failure to Diagnose a Stroke
    • GP Negligence
    • Misdiagnosis of Cancer
    • Negligent Treatment of Broken Bones
    • Sepsis Negligence
    • Vaginal & Perineal Tears
  • Dental Negligence
    • Dental Implants & Crowns
  • Road Traffic Accident
  • Slips, Trips & Falls
  • Vibration White Finger
Facebook
Twitter
Menu
  • About Us
    • Blog
    • Meet Our Team
    • Testimonials
    • Terms & Conditions
    • Privacy Policy
  • FAQs
  • Accident at Work
  • Asbestos & Mesothelioma
    • Mesothelioma
    • Pleural Thickening
    • Asbestosis
    • Pleural Effusion
    • Pleural Plaque
    • Lung Cancer
  • Medical Negligence
    • Accident & Emergency
    • Appendicitis
    • Bowel Injuries
    • Cauda Equina Syndrome
    • Failure to Diagnose a Stroke
    • GP Negligence
    • Misdiagnosis of Cancer
    • Negligent Treatment of Broken Bones
    • Sepsis Negligence
  • Dental Negligence
  • Road Traffic Accident
  • Slips, Trips & Falls
  • Vibration White Finger
  • Contact Us
ť»)

Difficulties in Diagnosing Asbestosis

February 9, 2021Thompson & Co SolicitorsNews

 

One of the difficulties in diagnosing asbestosis is in distinguishing it from other similar fibrotic lung conditions, which are grouped together under the term “idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis”, or IPF. This simply means fibrosis of unknown origin or cause.  

 

Diagnosis of Asbestosis during Lifetime

 

During a person’s lifetime a diagnosis will usually be made based on the following five criteria for diagnosing asbestosis:

 

i)     a history of moderate to heavy exposure – usually defined as being about one year of exposure in an activity of heavy exposure such as spraying of asbestos, lagging, or stripping. Moderate exposure is usually considered to be equivalent to five to 10 years of more intermittent exposure such as is typical in construction or shipbuilding. 

ii)     the presence of end-inspiratory crackles when a respiratory physician listens breathing using a stethoscope.

iii)    the presence of reticular linear diffuse opacities on the X-rays or the CT scans. This is a net-like pattern and a radiologist or chest physician will identify whether or not that feature is present.

iv)    restrictive impairment of lung function.

v)     the presence of pleural plaques which is a marker of asbestos exposure. 

 

Even if these criteria are satisfied however the difficulty remains that they do not help to distinguish asbestosis from IPF.

The risk of contracting asbestosis is connected with the dose of asbestos that the person has been exposed to over their lifetime. 

A dose of 25 fibre/ml years is associated with a 1 per cent risk of developing asbestosis. 

In a heavy exposure case of 100 fibre/ml years the risk increases to about 10 per cent.

The risk of contracting IPF in men over 75 is only 0.16%. The balance of probabilities therefore favours a diagnosis of asbestosis in cases of exposure of 25 fibre/mls years or more. 

 

Diagnosis of Asbestosis after Death

 

If a person is suspected of having died of an asbestos-related illness the matter should be referred to the coroner and a post-mortem will usually be carried out so that an analysis of lung tissue can be done. 

 

The lungs will initially be examined by the pathologist to ascertain the pattern of any lung fibrosis suffered. However the problem of distinguishing between asbestosis and IPF and, in particular, the most common sub-type of IPF which is usual interstitial pneumonia (UIP) still exists. 

 

More aggressive, rapidly progressing fibrosis will usually suggest a diagnosis of IPF such as UIP is more likely. However, in some cases of asbestosis, the pattern of the fibrosis resembles UIP.

 

Examination of Tissue Samples for Asbestos Bodies

 

     i) Dry Lung Tissue

 

Given the difficulties in distinguishing between the different types of lung fibrosis it is therefore also usually necessary to examine lung tissue samples to try to ascertain the number of asbestos bodies in the lungs.  Asbestos bodies are fibres that have been breathed into the lungs and which then become coated in iron. The asbestos bodies are highlighted by staining of the tissue samples. There are two types of stain: the first is haematoxylin and eosin (H & E staining); the second is iron staining, sometimes referred to as Perl’s staining. Iron staining can highlight more asbestos bodies than H&E staining. It is not clear from the post-mortem whether both of these stains were used in this case.  

The basic test is to examine the stained tissue samples looking for an average of two asbestos bodies per square centimetre of lung tissue under a light microscope.

There have been doubts expressed as to the reliability of an analysis of dry lung tissue carried out at post mortem. 

 

ii)    Wet Lung Tissue

 

Further studies can be carried out on tissue samples that have been treated with chemicals (wet lung tissue) to try to identify more accurately the extent of the asbestos material in the lungs. 

A count of asbestos bodies is made per gram of wet lung tissue. Broadly 1,000 asbestos bodies per gram of wet lung tissue equates to one asbestos body per square centimetre of dry tissue. A finding by this method of 2,000 asbestos bodies per gram of wet lung tissue would therefore usually be suggestive of asbestosis. 

However, there remains a problem when analyzing lung tissue samples for asbestos bodies that some people, for reasons that are not well understood breathe fibres into their lungs which do not then become coated in iron to form asbestos bodies. Consequently, a count of asbestos bodies may underestimate the amount of asbestos in the lungs. 

 

    iii) Electron Microscopic Analysis of Asbestos Fibres

 

Another option is to carry out an asbestos fibre analysis of the lung tissue samples using an electron microscope which is the most accurate technique for identifying the number of asbestos fibres within the lungs. This is not only able to more accurately ascertain the number of fibres in the tissue samples but also the type of asbestos fibres. 

The results of the tissue analysis will be compared against the range of the laboratory’s results from people who have been accepted as having asbestosis. If the fibre count is above the level required by the laboratory, asbestosis is diagnosed.

 

Thompson & Co Solicitors

Thompson & Co Personal Injury Solicitors has been providing specialist advice to members of the public in Personal injury, clinical negligence and related matters for over 20 years.

Just wanted to say a huge “thank you” Jacqui for everything you’ve done. I was so reluctant at the the beginning, to undertake a claim, fearing a daunting process but your assistance, advice ( & patience!) ensured it wasn’t so and I’ll always be grateful for that.

With very best wishes and sincere thanks,

“..very good contact from day one until case closed. Everything explained along the way, very helpful in all departments…cannot fault the level of service I have had during my time with Thompson & Co.”

Mrs M

“Helen at all times was very understanding and explained very clearly what was going to happen in our case. Very easy to talk to and very patient. I would have no problem in recommending Helen to someone else.  The level of service was excellent. We would like to pass on our thanks to Helen for her support and professionalism.”

I was at ease after our first meeting… We would like to thank Mark and all the team at Thompson & Co for everything they have done for us. The professionalism, dedication to detail was second to none. I would recommend Thompson & Co to anyone. They do a great job. Thanks again Mark for all the help you have given me.

Mr & Mrs P, Durham

“We would like to thank you for everything you have done for us. For your kindness and consideration whilst dealing with the claim. We will never forget your dedication and hard work on our behalf”

Mr & Mrs C

I would like to say a massive thank you for everything you have done for me regarding my claim… I have now received an apology from the hospital and have been reassured that lessons have been learned……I have been one hundred percent happy with the service and professionalism I have received from you. … I felt like I was chatting to a friend..Once again, thank you so much

Mrs N

The whole service I received throughout the process was very professional, informative and very clear every step of the way. The firm was recommended to me by a family member…The service throughout was exceptional.

Mr R

I found you willing to be patient with me at a very traumatic time in my life. You showed great empathy towards me and helped me resolve my claim for which I will be forever grateful.

Mr C

Ease of Process, good communication, helpful and professional service

Anonymous

I can never thank you enough for supporting me and my family in finding out what actually took place and holding out most importantly…..  for the truth and a apology….

Speaking on behalf of my family I can only say ” we are indebted to you for all your help”  and that we welcome any opportunity to promote not only your professionalism,  but the genuine kindness you afforded to us.

Anonymous

Accreditation Personal Injury Solicitors
Solicitors Regulation Authority
Apil

THOMPSON & CO. SOLICITORS
9 GREEN TERRACE
SUNDERLAND
TYNE & WEAR
ENGLAND
SR1 3PZ

PRINCIPAL: PHILIP C. THOMPSON
SRA ID NO. 191341

Our Services

  • Accident at Work
  • Asbestos Claims & Mesothelioma
  • Medical Negligence Claims
  • Road Traffic Accident Claims
  • Slips, Trips & Falls
  • Vibration White Finger
  • Blog
  • Thompson & Co Solicitors

Recent Posts

  • Difficulties in Diagnosing Asbestosis February 9, 2021
  • HSE Releases Figures for Great Britain 2020 November 27, 2020
  • Mesothelioma Compensation Claims October 31, 2020

Authorised & Regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority
The Authority’s Rules can be accessed at www.rules.sra.org.uk

Facebook
Twitter
Google+
Instagram

Copyright 2017 © Digital NRG Ltd.

Menu
  • Thompson & Co Solicitors

    Thompson & Co Personal Injury Solicitors has been providing specialist advice to members of the public in Personal injury, clinical negligence and related matters for over 20 years.

  • This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish.Accept Read More
    Privacy & Cookies Policy

    Privacy Overview

    This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
    Necessary
    Always Enabled

    Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.

    Non-necessary

    Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.

    SAVE & ACCEPT
    COVID-19
    An Important Update
    Read More
    X